Student Name:

Grade: Requirements:

• Introduction - general description of the topic and statement of the issues involved in the topic from what you gather from the papers.
  Comments:

• Summary - summarize each paper in terms of: the problem addressed, the general approach, and contributions. You should target 1-3 paragraphs on each paper here.
  Comments:

• Critique - contrast and compare the work of the various papers with each other, in terms of the problems addressed, contributions, and limitations. Offer your own critique of the work and topic in general as best you can from this limited treatment of the topic.
  Comments:

• Bibliography - include citations to the papers plus any other resources that you use.
  Comments:

Aspect	Metric	Your Grade
Technical Content	1-inaccurate or missing key points; little/no comparison/critique 2-ok on most key points; missing some key points;little critique or comparison 3-reasonable, average; fair summary; little comparison or justified critique 4-very good, summarized key points well; some comparison; decent critique 5-excellent, summarized key points well; compared papers well; great critique!
Writing Style	1-couldn't follow much; poor grammar; spelling errors 2-got lost often in your points; some grammar problems 3-reasonable, average; grammar/spelling ok, but some flow problems 4-well organized, above average; smooth flow of thoughts;few grammar/spelling problems 5-excellent, one of the best written summaries; clear and concisely written; no grammar/spelling problems great technical writing style
Formatting	1-terrible; did not follow format; lacking bibliography 3-average, followed formatting; some key citations missing 5-exceptional, followed guidelines good bibliography